Who's Right?Neighbour's barbecue smoke: is it allowed in France?
Published · Updated
In short
In France, yes, as long as it's occasional: a barbecue now and then isn't an abnormal neighbour nuisance, even if it smokes. It can be penalised if it's frequent and long, meant to annoy, damages your home, or breaks a local order or building rules.
Both sides
Since spring, Thomas has been firing up his charcoal grill almost every weekend, and often on Wednesday evenings too. His grill is right up against the fence, next to my patio. The smoke comes in through my windows and my laundry ends up smelling like a cookout. I'm not asking him to stop. I just want to eat outside without coughing.
I'm in my own garden, grilling at normal times, like everyone does in summer. I'm not trying to bother Nadia: the wind carries the smoke and I can't control that. We're talking about an hour, not a whole evening. If you can't have a barbecue at home anymore, what's next?
The verdict
On the main point, Thomas is right. Having a barbecue in your own garden is allowed, and smoke that drifts over now and then because of the wind is part of living next to other people. Nothing suggests he's doing it to annoy Nadia, and his timing is reasonable.
But Nadia's complaint is real and specific. A barbecue twice a week, right against the fence next to her patio, is no longer really occasional. And saying "I can't control the wind" doesn't help when he could just move the grill.
So Thomas wins on his right to grill. Nadia is right to ask him to think about where he sets up and how often.
The compromise
Thomas moves his grill away from the fence, out of the wind that blows toward Nadia's patio, and uses dry charcoal. He gives her a heads-up the day before so she can bring in her laundry and close her windows, and they agree on one barbecue-free evening a week.
What the rules say
Using a barbecue now and then is not considered an abnormal neighbour nuisance, even if it gives off smoke and smells, as long as the bother is occasional and unintentional (because of the wind, for example). However, a court may treat frequent, long use as a nuisance. The same goes if the barbecue is used to annoy the neighbour, or if it damages their home (a wall blackened by smoke, ash blowing over).
A municipal or prefectoral order may restrict barbecues, for example at certain times of year: check with your town hall. In a co-owned building or a housing estate, the co-ownership rules or the estate's specifications can limit or ban barbecues. A lease can also set rules. If these rules are broken, you can tell the building manager or the mayor.
Recommended steps: talk to the neighbour first, then send a simple letter, then a formal notice by registered letter with acknowledgement of receipt. After that, you can turn to a court conciliator (free), a mediator or a participatory procedure. This attempt at a friendly solution is required before going to court. The judge can then order the nuisance to stop, possibly with a daily penalty, and award compensation. Getting help from a lawyer is recommended.
Sources:
- Que faire en cas d'utilisation abusive d'un barbecue par un voisin ? (service-public.gouv.fr)
- Barbecue, réglementation et voisinage : que devez-vous respecter ? (anil.org)
General information, not legal advice.
Who do you think is right?
Pick a side.
Frequently asked questions
Can you have a barbecue on a balcony in a French flat?
There's no general ban. But the co-ownership rules or your lease can limit or ban barbecues, so check with your building manager or landlord.
Can the mayor ban barbecues?
Yes. A municipal or prefectoral order can restrict barbecues, for example at certain times of year. Only your town hall can tell you what applies where you live.
How do I prove barbecue smoke is an abnormal nuisance?
You need to show the bother is frequent and long, or that it causes damage, like a blackened wall or ash. Write down dates and durations, take photos, and gather as much evidence as you can before writing to your neighbour.
Do I have to see a conciliator before going to court?
Yes. An attempt at a friendly solution is required before going to court, for example through a court conciliator, which is free.
What can a judge order against a neighbour whose barbecue smokes you out?
The judge can order the nuisance to stop, possibly with a daily penalty. They can also award damages for harm to your property and to your peace and quiet.
Guide Disputes between neighbors: the guide
Written with the help of AI · This is not legal advice. How Who's Right decides
Comments
No comments yet. Be the first to give your opinion!