Who's Right?Dog poop outside the building: who should clean it up?
Published · Updated
In short
It's first up to the dog's owner to pick up after their own pet, wherever it is. In France, cleaning the pavement usually depends on the town, and shared areas fall to the building's management or landlord, not to a neighbour picked at random.
Both sides
I live on the ground floor, and almost every morning there's dog mess right by the front door. I'm sick of weaving around it with the pushchair. Élodie is the only one in the building with a dog, so it seems obvious she should deal with it. I asked her to clean the entrance and she nearly laughed in my face.
I always pick up after my dog, I have bags in every pocket. The pavement outside the building is a busy walkway, dozens of dogs go past every day. I'm not going to clean up after the whole neighbourhood just because I'm the only dog owner here. It's unfair to be blamed without any proof.
The verdict
Karim has a point: finding dog mess at the entrance every morning is a real hygiene and comfort problem, and wanting it to stop is fair. But he jumps to conclusions by singling out Élodie just because she owns a dog. Without having seen her leave anything behind, asking her to clean the entrance amounts to accusing her.
Élodie is right that she doesn't have to clean up after other people's dogs. Each owner is responsible for their own animal. Still, brushing off Karim's complaint doesn't help anyone: she's affected by the problem too and could be an ally.
The real target isn't the neighbour, it's the problem itself. It gets solved through the town council, the building's management or the landlord, plus a bit of talking.
The compromise
Karim withdraws his request and apologises for his tone. Together, they write a note to the building's management or landlord to report the problem, and Karim contacts the town's street cleaning service. Élodie, who walks her dog early, notes the times she sees unsupervised dogs by the entrance.
Who do you think is right?
Pick a side.
Frequently asked questions
Do dog owners have to pick up after their dogs?
Yes, it's basic good manners, and many French towns also require it. Penalties and fines vary from one town to another, so check with your local town hall.
Who cleans the pavement outside a building?
In France, it depends on the town. It's often the council's cleaning services, but some towns ask residents to look after the stretch of pavement in front of their home. Your town hall can confirm.
What if the mess is in the lobby or the building's courtyard?
Then it's a shared area, which is the responsibility of the co-owners' association or the landlord. Report it to the building manager or caretaker so they can clean it and remind everyone of the rules.
What should I do if I know which neighbour is responsible?
Start by talking to them calmly, in private and without accusations. If nothing changes, tell the building manager or landlord, who can send them a written reminder.
Can I put up a sign in the building about it?
Yes, but ask the building manager or landlord first. A polite general message works better than a note aimed at one person.
Guide Disputes between neighbors: the guide
Written with the help of AI · This is not legal advice. How Who's Right decides
Comments
No comments yet. Be the first to give your opinion!