Who's Right?Neighbor parks in my space when I'm away: is it OK?
Published · Updated
In short
In France, parking in someone else's private space without permission is not a right, even if it's empty. The holder can say no.
Both sides
I paid for this space, and I often spend weekends at my parents' place. Twice I came home early and found Youssef's car in it. I had to circle the neighborhood for twenty minutes with my suitcases. It's not about an empty space: he never asked me, and it feels like he's helping himself to my things.
The space sits empty for days, and parking on our street is a nightmare. I only use it when I can see Camille is gone, and I always meant to move before she got back. I don't damage anything or block anyone. To me it was just a small favor between neighbors, not theft.
The verdict
Camille has the stronger case. A private parking space is a bit like a cellar or a garden: being empty doesn't make it free to use. The real issue is that nobody agreed to anything. Youssef set up the arrangement on his own, and Camille pays the price when she comes home early.
That doesn't mean Youssef acted in bad faith. His need is real, he causes no damage, and he tries to leave before she returns. But "I meant to move in time" isn't enough: he can't know her schedule, and it has already gone wrong twice.
This isn't a big drama, but it's a real nuisance, and it can quickly sour things between neighbors. The fix is to ask first, not to quietly help yourself.
The compromise
Youssef apologizes and stops using the space without asking. If Camille agrees, they put in writing the days she's away and swap phone numbers. Youssef promises to free the space within the hour if she comes back early.
What the rules say
In a private car park where the Highway Code doesn't apply (for example a gated residential car park), the French Highway Code (Code de la route) says that vehicles left there "without right" can be impounded at the request of the "maître des lieux" (the person in charge of the premises), at their own responsibility (article L325-12). You make the request to the local judicial police officer, at the police or gendarmerie station (article R325-47). If you know the car owner's name and address, you must attach proof that you sent them a formal notice by letter with acknowledgment of receipt, giving them 8 days from receipt to remove the car (article R325-48). If you don't know who they are, you attach a request to identify them. Towing and storage fees are paid by the vehicle's owner (article L325-9). If the car park is open to public traffic, different rules may apply. In a co-owned building, also check what your building's rules (règlement de copropriété) say.
Sources:
- Sous-section 2 : Véhicules laissés sans droit dans des lieux non ouverts à la circulation publique. (Articles R325-47 à R325-52) - Légifrance (legifrance.gouv.fr)
- Article L325-12 - Code de la route - Légifrance (legifrance.gouv.fr)
- Chapitre 5 : Immobilisation et mise en fourrière. (Articles L325-1 à L325-14) - Légifrance (legifrance.gouv.fr)
General information, not legal advice.
Who do you think is right?
Pick a side.
Frequently asked questions
Can I have my neighbor's car towed right away?
Usually not, in a private car park closed to the public. The Highway Code says to go through the judicial police officer. If you know the owner, you first have to send a formal notice by letter with acknowledgment of receipt, giving them 8 days to move the car.
Who pays if the car is towed?
Under the French Highway Code, towing and impound storage fees are paid by the vehicle's owner.
What should I do before going that far?
Talk to your neighbor calmly first, or leave a polite note. If it happens again, put it in writing so you have a record. The towing procedure is mostly useful when a car stays in your space for a long time.
Can I block their car with mine to teach them a lesson?
Better not. You risk making the conflict worse and putting yourself in the wrong too. Talk first, then use the proper procedure.
What if I'm happy to lend my space?
That's up to you. Set clear rules in writing: which days, what times, and what happens if you come back early.
Guide Disputes between neighbors: the guide
Written with the help of AI · This is not legal advice. How Who's Right decides
Comments
No comments yet. Be the first to give your opinion!